Following the echo, the patient was put on enalapril 2.5mg bid and furosemide 12.5 mg bid. She responded well with medications. Pimobendan would have been an additional choice but not implemented. Unfortunately, she developed kidney and liver disease. At that time the owners elected humane euthanasia.

Survival tears can occur but usually have blood clots but not always. The actual tear is very difficult to find and was the case in this patient and extensive interrogation to find the tear in a stressed critical patient is not ideal as these patients are very very fragile. High resolution and the luck of the angle is usually necessary as the tear is usually small if the patient is still alive. The wall being thin also leads to echo drop out and tough to follow to begin with. In this case the mitral jet was directed to the roof of the left atrium in this patient so the atrial wall wears thin “like a hole in an old sock” as a cardiologist friend put it and the LA “roof” would have been the area to look for the tear here.
The more and more we run into scenarios such as this we find that occasionally some quality of life can be managed with small tears. Differentials of pericardial effusion of course include neoplasia, pericarditis, CHF (in cats primarily as dogs don’t typically have pericardial effusion in CHF but can occasionally happen and there is a minor chance that that is the case here but rare just the same). and idiopathic causes. But the point of the discussion is that when pericardial effusion occurs in light of severe valvular disease in predisposed breeds its usually a “something has gotta give” scenario and occasionally we see them still alive with the probe.
After discussing with cardiologists about this case in their experience, if a tear is recent there is usually a pericardial blood clot and when stabilized the clot can resolve, the hole can seal normalizing the pressure gradient and the patient can occasionally stabilize. Again, its rare but it happens. This may have been the case here. Unfortunately, post mortem was not available to confirm.